A 1941 law set the U.S. federal Thanksgiving holiday on the fourth Thursday of November, starting in 1942. In a November with four Thursdays, the fourth one is also the last. When there are five, the fourth comes a week earlier. The Senate chose that rule after President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week and states split over which date to observe. The House agreed, and Roosevelt signed the rule into law.12
What happens when November has five Thursdays?
Start with November 1939. The Thursdays were November 2, 9, 16, 23 and 30. Count from the start of the month and the fourth Thursday lands on the 23rd. Start at the end and the last Thursday lands on the 30th. That extra Thursday is the only thing that makes the two rules disagree. In a November with four Thursdays, both rules point to the same square.
The country had a tradition of using that last Thursday. In 1863, during the Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln called for a day of thanksgiving on the last Thursday of that November. Later presidents generally followed the custom by issuing their own proclamations, or formal announcements. They could pick a different date. Andrew Johnson chose the first Thursday in December in 1865, and Ulysses S. Grant chose the third Thursday in November in 1869.3456
Why did states celebrate a week apart?
President Franklin D. Roosevelt looked at that November 30 date in 1939 and saw a short Christmas shopping season. Retailers had asked for more time between Thanksgiving and Christmas, hoping people would buy more during the Great Depression. Roosevelt proclaimed November 23 as Thanksgiving, leaving an extra week between the holiday and Christmas. Some states followed him and others kept November 30. If your state kept November 30 and your sister’s state followed Roosevelt, her day off could come a week before yours.6710
Roosevelt used the same rule in 1940 and 1941. He picked the Thursday one week before the last. Both Novembers had four Thursdays, so November 21 in 1940 and November 20 in 1941 were each the third Thursday. The 1939 date happened to be the fourth Thursday because that November had five. The rule Congress eventually adopted works differently. It moves the holiday a week earlier than the old custom only when a fifth Thursday shows up.8912
Who picked the fourth Thursday?
In October 1941, the House of Representatives voted for the old last-Thursday rule. The Senate changed one word, from “last” to “fourth.” Senator John Danaher of Connecticut explained that the revised rule kept the familiar date in years with four Thursdays and avoided pushing Thanksgiving to the very end of the month in years with five. A law would also give everyone a date they could work out in advance.61
The House agreed to the change, and Roosevelt signed it on December 26, 1941. The federal rule took effect the following year. In 1942, November 26 was both the fourth and the last Thursday. Some states kept their own observance for a while. In 1950, another November with five Thursdays, several states still observed November 30 while the federal holiday fell on November 23.210
Today the U.S. Code still sets Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday. The first Thursday can fall anywhere from November 1 to November 7. Three weeks later, the fourth lands between November 22 and November 28. To find it, count four Thursdays from the start of November. If another Thursday follows, you’ve already found Thanksgiving.11
