The short answer

Pluto is a dwarf planet because it has yet to clear its orbital neighborhood. Its own gravity has pulled it into a nearly round shape, and it orbits the Sun. What sets Pluto apart from the eight planets is how much gravitational influence it has over the other bodies near its orbit.12

Which test does Pluto miss?

A close-up of Pluto shows a round world. Track it across the sky for long enough and you can trace its path around the Sun. Those observations account for two of the three conditions in the International Astronomical Union’s definition of a planet in our solar system.13

The third condition asks what else moves through that part of space. Over time, a planet’s gravity shapes the orbits of the smaller bodies in its neighborhood. Astronomers call this clearing the neighborhood.12

Does a planet need a completely empty orbit?

Earth has company on its trip around the Sun. In 2011 astronomers announced the discovery of a small asteroid that travels ahead of Earth and keeps pace with it. Earth still qualifies as a planet. Its gravity can shape a neighbor’s path even when that neighbor stays put in the same region.14

Now zoom out from Pluto. Its five moons are a good sign of its local pull. Farther out, though, Pluto shares the Kuiper Belt with a whole population of icy worlds. It has never come to dominate its orbital neighborhood the way Earth has.123

What changed in 2006?

Astronomers had counted Pluto as the ninth planet since its discovery in 1930. Then, in 2005, a team announced another world about Pluto’s size. If Pluto was the ninth planet, should this newcomer, later named Eris, be the tenth?2

In 2006 the International Astronomical Union adopted the orbital-neighborhood test as part of its definition. That put Pluto and Eris in the dwarf planet category and left eight planets. Nine years later, NASA’s New Horizons spacecraft flew past Pluto. In those first close-ups, astronomers could finally see the mountains of water ice on a world they had known for decades as a dot in the sky.1235